Tuesday, July 16, 2024

    Balancing AI And Human Expertise: A Bi faceted Approach To Software Testing

    As AI becomes increasingly integrated into software development, the role of human testers is evolving. AI can automate repetitive testing tasks at scale but lacks human judgment, intuition, and domain expertise. A balanced, multifaceted approach that leverages the strengths of both AI and human testers promises more comprehensive and effective validation of applications and services.

    This blog post explores how to optimally combine AI automation with human expertise for software testing services.

    The Role Of AI In Testing:

    AI is already streamlining many routine testing activities.

    • Automated test case generation analyzes requirements to output comprehensive test scenarios.
    • Continuous integration runs the automated unit, integration, and API tests on every code change for rapid feedback.
    • Test data preparation synthesizes realistic data at scale for performance and load testing.
    • Defect prediction algorithms pinpoint code segments and features more likely to contain bugs. 
    • Test orchestration intelligently schedules and prioritizes test execution across environments.
    • Self-healing techniques detect and help resolve issues in testing pipelines to keep workflows running smoothly.

    This automation handles voluminous repetitive tasks, improves coverage, and allows human testers to focus on more strategic work. However, AI has limitations when complex judgment is required.

    The Role Of Human Testers:

    While AI streamlines routine testing, human testers provide indispensable capabilities:

    • Exploratory testing uses creativity and experience to surface unanticipated issues beyond automated scenarios.
    • Usability testing directly observes real users interacting with applications to identify friction points.
    • Compliance testing validates adherence to industry regulations requiring subject-matter expertise.
    • Security testing involves thinking like attackers to uncover vulnerabilities through penetration testing.
    • Performance testing in production-like environments is better done by experienced testers.
    • Test oversight ensures AI recommendations and results do not contain unintended biases or flaws.
    • Specialized testing roles like QA engineers and test analysts require human problem-solving skills.

    Combining The Two Approaches:

    An optimal strategy combines AI automation and human judgment through a faceted approach:

    • Automation handles voluminous regression testing to validate changes at scale.
    • Humans focus on new features through exploratory testing and usability research. 
    • AI aids test design based on coverage analysis, but humans have the final sign-off.
    • Automated tests execute continuously, with humans monitoring the results.
    • AI prioritizes failing tests for human debugging and root cause analysis.
    • Humans validate edge cases and unexpected outcomes beyond automation.
    • AI-human hybrid teams work together with bots to augment human capabilities.
    • Humans oversee AI systems, address limitations, and retrain models as needed.

    Challenges Of The Bifaceted Approach:

    • Combining AI and human testing also presents challenges.
    • Initial costs of building AI capabilities and upskilling tester skills
    • The complexity of integrating different tools, data sources, and technologies
    • Ensuring AI recommendations do not undermine human oversight and judgment
    • Addressing technical limitations or “bugs” in AI systems
    • Difficulty replicating human problem-solving, critical thinking, and common sense
    • Potential job disruptions if not implemented carefully with the reskilling of testers. 
    • Maintaining optimal human-AI collaboration as roles continually evolve
    • Lack of standards around how much testing can or should be reasonably automated

    Careful change management is required to overcome resistance, upskill teams, and ensure the benefits of automation outweigh the transition costs. Governance is also key to the success of any human-AI partnership approach.

    Change Management Considerations:

    To facilitate the adoption of the multifaceted model, organizations should:

    • Communicate the vision and benefits of leveraging both AI and human skills.
    • Provide learning and skilling programs to help testers adopt new toolsets and work styles.
    • Address fears around job disruption through retraining programs and career pathing.
    • Pilot the approach gradually in select areas and showcase early wins to gain buy-in.
    • Involve testers in the design and implementation process to secure ownership.
    • Establish governance frameworks defining human and AI responsibilities and oversight.
    • Monitor closely and be ready to course-correct based on feedback from testers and outcomes.
    • Recognize and reward testers who successfully adapt their roles and help others.
    • Communicate that the goal is to enhance testing capabilities, not full automation or replacement of humans.

    With the right change management, human experts can embrace AI as a productivity tool rather than a threat.

    Tools And Technologies:

    Leveraging the multifaceted approach requires integrating tools that support both AI automation and human judgment.

    • Test management platforms to record, track, and manage the full testing lifecycle.
    • Continuous integration servers to run automated tests on each code change.
    • AI assistants and chatbots to help with routine queries and administrative tasks.
    • Code quality analysis tools to detect defects and vulnerabilities for human review. 
    • Performance and load testing virtualization for realistic scenario modeling
    • Defect tracking systems are used to manage issues detected and prioritize resolution.
    • Simulation and synthetic data generation for complex scenario replication
    • Model-monitoring tools to validate AI systems catch regressions or biases.
    • Collaboration software to bring together distributed human-AI hybrid teams.

    Selecting tools that integrate AI capabilities while allowing for human oversight and customization is important for operationalizing the bifaceted approach.

    Bifaceted Testing In Action:

    Some examples of how specific testing types may leverage a multifaceted model are:

    Unit Testing: AI runs automated tests continuously; humans address failures.

    API Testing: AI prioritizes endpoints for testing; humans validate critical paths. 

    Security Testing: AI scans for vulnerabilities; pen-testers validate through manual exploration.

    Performance Testing: AI models load; humans test critical transactions in live environments.

    Compliance Testing: AI checks for policy violations; auditors make final determinations.

    A/B Testing: AI manages experiments; product managers review qualitative feedback.

    Exploratory Testing: AI suggests additional cases; testers have the freedom to discover new issues.

    The right mix of automation and human judgment will vary by context. The goal is to enhance outcomes through their synergy.


    As AI increasingly transforms software testing, a balanced approach that leverages the unique strengths of both AI and human testers promises more comprehensive validation.

    By strategically combining automation with human expertise through a multifaceted model, organizations can maximize benefits while overcoming the limitations of each approach. With careful change management, reskilling, and governance, AI augments rather than replaces testers, creating exciting new opportunities to advance the profession. A collaborative human-AI dynamic paves the way for testing in the future.

    Evan Gilbort
    Evan Gilbort
    I am working as a software developer focused on technologies, experience creating web development application for small and enterprise level and also middle tier solutions.

    Related Articles


    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Stay Connected

    - Advertisement -spot_img

    Latest Articles